Also, is there a version of DonRockwell.com for NYC? Egullet seems OK, but is surprisingly inactive. Is there something I'm missing?
Five years later ...
The Mother Thread is too much work to split up, so will remain as a historical document, and perhaps separated on a piecemeal basis once new threads get rolling. For now, let's make it read only, with quoted replies going into individual restaurant threads. There's no reason we shouldn't have a solid New York City forum up and running in the not-too-distant future.
