Jump to content

Maggie's, A Reincarnation of the Tenleytown Pizza Institution at 4914 Cordell Avenue in Bethesda - Closed


Recommended Posts

Looked to be closed tonight. Didn't get a good look at the sign in the window, but seemed to be an application to transfer the beer/wine license to something called Maggie's.

It's not just any old Maggie's; it's *the* Maggie's - the legendary Tenleytown pizzeria that was there from 1950-1998.

In 1964, Joe Trilling purchased the pizzeria from the original owner, Phil "Maggie" Magenello, and owned it for 34 years.

Jeff Trilling, owner of the new Bethesda Maggie's, is Joe's son, so there is more than just a nominal link to the old institution.

You stumbled across a noteworthy story, mnnchas!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's not just any old Maggie's; it's *the* Maggie's - the legendary Tenleytown pizzeria that was there from 1950-1998.

In 1964, Joe Trilling purchased the pizzeria from the original owner, Phil "Maggie" Magenello, and owned it for 34 years.

Jeff Trilling, owner of the new Bethesda Maggie's, is Joe's son, so there is more than just a nominal link to the old institution.

You stumbled across a noteworthy story, mnnchas!

And the teenagers who drank there in the 90s are now thirty and fortysomethings living in Bethesda ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And the teenagers who drank there in the 90s are now thirty and fortysomethings living in Bethesda ;)

I can safely say that at this time yesterday, I couldn't have possibly imagined we'd have threads for V3 and Maggie's.

Can't wait to see how much customer overlap these two places have.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting...turns out it's really more of a Wing Hub/Maggie's hybrid.

"Wing Hub Reopening As Maggie's" by Carole Sugarman on bethesdamagazine.com

Thanks, mtureck for linking to Carole Sugarman's article in Bethesda Magazine. I was catching up on the City Paper's Young & Hungry blog and found Stephanie Haven's take on the "rebranding" of Wing Hub.

The switchover, first reported by Bethesda magazine, will mean more than a name change. Maggie's will remain a sports bar, just one that Trilling hopes will be more accessible to women. It will have the same wings as Wing Hub but several new additions, like New York-style pizza and a tiki bar on the patio. "So many girls I know wouldn't come in more than once or twice a month," says Trilling. "I asked them if they'd come in if I changed the restaurant name to Maggie's, and their instant reaction is, "˜Absolutely.'"

The name is an homage to a Tenleytown pizzeria called Maggie's, first opened in the 1950s, that Trilling's father owned from 1964 to 1979. After he sold it, the original Maggie's continued to operate until 1998. "Playboy had them as the No. 1 one bar in the country for a ridiculous number of years," Trilling says. (Although he probably shouldn't tell that to the women he's trying to attract to the restaurant.)

Here's Stephanie Haven's photo that accompanied her Y&H blog post:

DSC_0640.jpeg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I first went to Maggie's in '63 as a junior in high school with a friend who was a freshman at A. U. We went a lot, sometimes with others and were never carded. Although I didn't like beer we thought we would impress girls-mostly from A. U.-who walked in and saw us drinking. The key was we would never let anyone take the mugs away. With four of us at the table and a couple of hours we could fill the entire table top. We thought we were cool.

And macho.

At some point on these trips we realized we needed "dinner" and Maggie's had pizza for $ .50. Yes, fifty cents. It was good, or at least it seemed so when we could buy two pies for a buck. Should I mention that a Mighty Mo was fifty five cents then?

Maggie's was an institution in the '60's. My first job was at the Hot Shoppes at Wisconsin and Van Ness (Broadcast House today) with occasional trips with my A. U. friend after work. In truth I never liked beer but I did like their cheap pizza.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maggie's was an institution in the '60's. My first job was at the Hot Shoppes at Wisconsin and Van Ness (Broadcast House today) with occasional trips with my A. U. friend after work.

Wasn't that Hot Shoppes where McDonalds is now, next door to Broadcast House?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wasn't that Hot Shoppes where McDonalds is now, next door to Broadcast House?

The Hot Shoppes and its parking lot were on the ground that Broadcast House is now on. I'm not sure exactly where the McDonald's is.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The McDonalds sits in the middle of a parking lot that's on the southwest corner of Wisconsin and Van Ness. Broadcast House is its neighbor to the south. I'm pretty sure that before it was a McDonalds it was a Roy Rogers, another Marriott brand. It's too bad that it's not easy to look this kind of thing up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It was Roy Rogers when I first moved to DC in 1996. McDonald's was where ZBurger is now. After RR closed and McDonald's moved to that property, the space that currently houses ZBurger had a couple of different non-food businesses for a number of years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great, because what Bethesda really needs is another pizza place!

Sigh.

Wing Hubs wings took a dip in quality a while back...went from tasty small wings to bigger wings that weren't as good...but it was still nice to have them there.

 

For what it's worth Maggie's is also now closed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The original Maggies next to Armands (also gone but never forgotten) on Wisconsin served mediocre pizza but it was pretty cheap. However, Armands had their daily lunch buffet with all the salad and pizza one could consume so why bother with Maggies??

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...