Between Todd Kliman's recent plug (cannot find the link), and Synaesthesia's
Plea for P, I decided it was time to return to Montsouris.
First of all, please DO support southside P street - there's construction going on right now, but the valet parking at Pesce, Montsouris, etc. remains ridiculously cheap at $5.00, and all you need to do is simply turn onto Hopkins Street (easily done from either direction), pull over, and the valets will come right over to your car. It's as easy as it's ever been. All of these restaurants were empty at 7 PM on a Friday night, and yes, they do need your support right now.
Le Steak du Boucher ($19) translates to "Le Steak of the Boucher," and is a fibrous little square served alongside mashed potatoes made with bacon, chives, and creme fraiche. An
Entrecote Bearnaise ($22) is more buttery and polished, and the little cast-iron pan of irresistible potato gratin makes it worth the extra money. Both steaks were ordered medium-rare, and served medium-rare - this is rare.
Desserts are made in-house and worth ordering. A
Creme de pistache is a small bowl of not-too-sweet, thankfully non-granular cream that shouldn't be dismissed just because of the "pot au creme" semi-fad going on in this town. A
Poire Belle Helene is bowling-alley-bistro food in France, but it's often good even at bowling-alley-bistros, and so it is here. A whole pear, bathing in chocolate sauce, and funneled up with whipped cream on top.
Service was friendly, the atmosphere is everything you should want in a French steak-bistro, the wines were well-chosen and served at the proper temperature (even the reds), the steaks were very good, the sides of potatoes were great, and other than the Bearnaise sauce which remains too full of tarragon (yeah, I know, it's "supposed" to be) and the maddeningly mediocre bread, Montsouris should remain on your short list of places to revisit.
Cheers,
Rocks.