QUOTE (ferment everything @ Feb 24 2008, 01:19 PM)

this looks good but calls for veal stock. I could buy veal stock, but I'd love to make a version that didn't require adding stock, and rather relies mostly on the oxtail (and the protein raft) for flavor. Is this a bad idea? Should I just buy some veal stock? Or turn this into an all-out project and make my own before making the consomme?
I ended up doing an approximation, and it turned out ok. I started the stock with normal beef bones (which take longer to cook) and augmented with the oxtails after 2 hours of simmering. Strained, chilled, removed the fat layer (a solid fat layer!) to reveal delightfully jiggly (gelatin!) stock underneath. This was a first for me: both of my attempts at chicken stock have yielded liquids without solid fat layers on top.
With the cooled jiggly stock, I then tried the protein raft thing: used 1/2lb ground beef, 4 egg whites, and some chopped onion and celery. I blended that in the food processor, then stirred it into the cool stock and put it on low heat. Even after it got to a simmer and stayed that way for a good 20 minutes, it never really solidified into the expected solid raft of protein. I ended up just straining it through some cheesecloth and a sieve. It wasn't as clear as I'd hoped, but it still tasted real good.
The meal I ended up cooking was the following:
Canapé of reserved oxtail meat, guanciale
Oxtail Consommé and dumplings
Braised pork shoulder, shaved brussels sprouts, Consommé jelly
For the canapés, I made a roux-based sauce with some of the consommé, mixed that with the reserved oxtail, blended the combination with some homemade mustard. The layers went 1) bread 2) oxtail meat paste and 3) guanciale. The flavor was great, but could've used some more mustard, or maybe something else to balance out...these were very rich. Could've used some color too (shades of brown were running amok)
The consomme didn't start clear, and cooking dumplings in it didn't help. Also, I pulled the dumplings from a chicken/dumplings recipe and they weren't very good. This dish was not great. Would probably try filled dumplings next time, and maybe cooking the dumplings outside the stock, and dropping them in at the last second to keep the consommé from clouding. Still, the consommé itself was pretty tasty.
The pork shoulder was rubbed with leftover pastrami rub 24 hours in advance, then cooked in some citrus juice (1 orange, 1 grapefruit, 1 lemon) and some water. Brussels sprouts were blanched, then run through a mandolin, and pan-fried in butter. The consommé jelly was a whim: I just added one gelatin packet to some of the consommé, let it chill in the fridge for a few hours before dinner, and cut it into little cubes for plate garnish. It looked awesome but didn't taste very good: I hadn't added salt to the consommé yet, and in general I think it needed some other/more flavor to make it appetizing. The rest of the plate was a hit.
A couple pictures:
canapés:

shoulder, brussels, jelly:

Wow, this post was way longer than I anticipated it being. Thanks for listening