Kinkead's vs. Colvin Run Tavern

[diddy]

I got a gift certificate or Colvin Run, which can also be used at Kinkeads. Which one should I go to?

[Meaghan]

Kinky's. Colvin is disappointing.

[dcs]

I went to lunch at Colvin's close to a year ago and thought it was outstanding. Unfortunately, it was long enough ago that I forget what I ate. Maybe it was that flight of wine that I had with lunch. I do remember that the service was excellent. The only minor dissappointment was that the dessert cheeseplate had probably the thinnest slivers of cheese I have ever been served.

I went to Kinkead's for lunch about 6 months or so ago. The skate main course was top notch. The tomato based soup I had for an appetizer had a small clump of hair in it that I did not find until I was almost finished with the soup.

Overall, I more fondly remember my Colvin's experience.

[NoKaOi]

Definitely Kinkead's. The wife and I went to Colvin Run on Saturday night and although the food was adequate, it still left us somewhat disappointed and expecting more. The service also left something to be desired. I feel as if Kinkead's is never a letdown.

[RaisaB]

I think Kinkead's is more consistant than Colvin's. I also received a certificate as a present, I didn't know I could use it at Kinkead's! Thanks for the info.