Post or Pre Theater Meal

[L8yF8]

Due to a snafu we ended up with tickets to an afternoon showing of Billy Elliot on Sunday at 3pm and Mama Mia tickets the same day at 7pm. I would like to get a good meal in the theater district or nearby. If in between shows, something like a pre theater menu. Also willing to eat after the show but it will be probably around 9:30 on a Sunday night and we will be with a couple in their mid 60's who will not want to go to far before eating. Would appreciate any suggestions, Thanks.