I've been 3 times now to Eventide for dinner, and I really want to like it, so have hesitated to pass judgment. The space is fantastic, and I like the menu. Unfortunately on each of the 3 occasions we've been disappointed with our meals. Spotty service or questionable preparation on each occasion. I'm a fairly forgiving reviewer and the duck on my last visit was nearly inedible--overcooked to the point of being grey and rubbery--easily the worst duck I've ever had. I've never sent an entree back to the kitchen, but seriously considered it on this occasion. Our server didn't ask about the uneaten entrees. We've had a few highlights over the meals, but nothing exceptional - we're basically done. We think it is a pretty face, but lacks the food to back it up.
