Scarr's, Pizza by the Slice, Along with Whole Pies and Delivery - 22 Orchard Street, Lower East Side

[lekkerwijn]

On 10/19/2018 at 11:42 AM, Tweaked said:

Serious Eats dives deep in NYC slice culture

The only place to go right now is Scarr’s on the LES. That little write up doesn’t do it justice. Hands down the ultimate NYC pie. Also their subs and Caesar salad and natural wine list in a setting that is so throwback are perfection. 

[alexandria1]

Had a good "Sicilian" pepperoni slice from Scarr's a couple weeks ago. Even though it had probably been sitting for a while before reheating, the crust held up well, the sauce was heated to less-than-molten, and the cheese had the right texture. When I mentioned to local friends the next day that I was hunting for good slices of pizza on this visit, Scarr's was the first place they mentioned.

The slice I got from Prince Street a short while later was an underbaked disappointment despite being minutes out of the oven.