I'll admit my bias in that I'm a huge fan of Dan's cooking. Given that Seasonal Pantry is right around the corner from my job I probably pop in once a week on the way home to grab something to spice up my dinner. So far the highlights include:
*Housemade Bacon - gives the bacon from Bar 3 a run for the money, so wonderfully smokey and tasty, makes a fantastic amatriciana sauce.
*Pickled Cherries - spectacular with cheese, green, and pork
*Ice Cream - all of the flavors were delicious, my favorite so far has been the balsamic, which was almost caramel in flavor.
*Any of the pasta - seriously, do yourself a favor and get some, I don't care what shape. I haven't had pasta this good since Roma
What might be the best part is how personable Dan is when you're in there. He's extremely gracious and knowledgeable, when I was asked him what to do with them and he explained to me how to use them in cooking swiss chard....I cooked chard for 3 days in a row using the cherries. It was that good.
I hadn't been able to actually EAT at Seasonal Pantry until last night though as they had been sold out for several weeks following the Post review. Needless to say I was excited when they offered a "Dine and Dash" 3 course menu for $30 (or $40 for wine). I went with two of my coworkers and snagged a 9:30 dining time. You had the choice of:
1st Course: Pate de Champagne or peperonata
2nd Course: House made pasta with either: A) Smoked tomatoes and eggplant or B ) Rapini and italian sausage
3rd Course: Roasted Peaches with mascarpone and honey
We all went with the peperonata as our appetizer, you could taste the hours of roasting that went into the stew of of peppers and onions served over some great bread that was made in store. The pasta was wonderfully al dente, with nice bitter morsels of rapini and bites of sausage that popped with flavor. I was equally impressed with my vegetarian friend's pasta dish, which had these wonderful little smoked tomatoes scattered throughout the dish. It was nice to see that someone took extra time and care to make sure that the vegetarian entree was just as composed and interesting as the rest of the menu. The peaches with honey was divine, I contemplated licking the plate to get every drop of the creamy, sweet emulsion of the cheese and honey.
Given the price and quality of food, that would be enough as it is. But you have a really intimate experience at the place, the people serving you the food are Katie's parents. It just makes for a great time for all, both of my coworkers thanked me repeatedly for telling them about Seasonal Pantry.