Guilty as charged! Tom Brown was our waiter (I asked for him, as I've gotten to know him over the months as a wine rep), and I had to get the scallops as the first course (we were ordering a big gun Cabernet with our main, and ordered the steak special with port reduction sauce - awesome BTW), and I HAD to the get the scallops as my first course (based on the reviews on dr.com)... We had a GREAT TIME and the food was fantastic all around.
Corduroy IMO is the best all around restaurant in the city right now (food, service, the wine list... oh, the wine list!!!). We ordered a bottle of Littorai 2001 Chardonnay Theierot Vineyard (Ted Lemon is the only American EVER to have been a winemaker in Burgundy), and it was great with the scallops. I also brought a bottle of Sauzet 2002 Puligny Montrachet 1er Les Perrieres... needless to say, I could have had the scallops for first, main AND dessert!