I was in the dining room last night with some friends celebrating a gradutation. The biscuits and a nice little amuse of potato croquettes got things off on a nice foot, although the croquettes were NOT hot, and tasted as though they'd been out of the fryer for a few minutes. The biscuits are worthy of all the praise given in prior posts. Even better was a bison tartare with a good amount of cornichons and capers mixed in with the meat. Perfect balance of flavors to compliment but not overpower the strong taste of bison. Buttery, delicious, and a nice take on the classic. Plus a little of the cranberry mustard that came on the plate served me well when it made its way on my biscuit.
For entrees I went with the baby goat with achiote pappardelle. Just a fantastic plate of food. Smokey, rich (braised goat doesn't necessarily need coconut milk but lord knows it didn't mind it) and with a very generous portion of the braised meat. I almost wished it was 40 degrees colder because this would be a perfect winter dish. It was so damn good I didn't care though. The gf got the pork chop which suffered from the same slight undercooking as quoted above. The other flavors (sour cherries, a smashing side of chorizo) were spot on with this dish but it was too tough (read: underdone) for my taste. I also managed to steal one bite of our friend's lamb loin, which was perfectly cooked and delicious.
Despite a few minor temperature quibbles I came away VERY impressed with the service, presentation, and most importantly the quality of food coming out of the kitchen at Eventide. They're doing a hell of a job on the 2nd floor and while I could happily come back and order the exact same thing again I'm looking forward to trying the bar and roof menus as well.